2008 Primaries, Strategic Blueprints • May 13th, 2008

Will Wisconsin be McCain Country in ‘08?

by Chris Lato

For the last five presidential elections, Democrats have taken Wisconsin – the last two times by razor-thin margins.

What does this mean for self-styled maverick John McCain in 2008? His campaign advisors think Wisconsin is promising – so much so that moves are being made to ensure the Badger State flips from blue to red this year.

The Journal Sentinel article I linked to above points out McCain will have to run a different type of campaign to carry Wisconsin – reaching out to the independents, conservative-minded Democrats, etc.

That will have to happen – to a point. But the McCain campaign forgets about the base at its peril.

In 2000 and 2004, the GOP worked like dogs to pull off a massive get-out-the-vote effort on behalf of Pres. Bush. It took an army of people to pull it off, and it was tantalizingly close to a success. After that, though, people were burned out, and that intensity wasn’t there in 2006, when Mark Green needed that juice to beat Jim Doyle in the race for governor. That was one reason (but certainly not the only reason) why Green lost – people weren’t quite feeling it.

This time around, again, the base is still not on fire over their party’s standard-bearer. McCain, as we’ve said before, has burned a lot of bridges with conservatives and the level of drive isn’t there yet. It will have to be, and soon. A good indicator of where things are at will be at this weekend’s GOP state convention in Stevens Point.

Still, Senator Russ Feingold makes a pretty astute observation about Wisconsin and McCain. You’ll recall the two worked side by side for years on campaign finance ‘reform’ legislation. Feingold’s politics are not my cup of tea, but he’s no dummy. From the Journal Sentinel article:

Feingold, McCain’s Senate colleague, has repeatedly warned that beating McCain in the state will be a serious challenge…In an interview earlier this year, he said McCain is “a candidate who seems to be extremely conservative (but) will be very hard to characterize,” and added that, in Wisconsin, “it’s going to be tougher than winning it against Bush, and Bush barely lost it twice.”

That is the X-factor here. McCain’s ‘independent’ streak speaks to people in Wisconsin who have no qualms about voting for a Democrat governor and a Republican attorney general. And that is what McCain’s team hopes to capitalize on. The only question now is whether that will be enough to carry the state without a message that also speaks to the base.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, May 13th, 2008 at 8:56 am and is filed under 2008 Primaries, Strategic Blueprints. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

3 Responses to “Will Wisconsin be McCain Country in ‘08?”
  1. My new WordPress MU Site » Blog Archive » Will Wisconsin be McCain Country in ‘08? Says:


    […] Real Debate wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptFor the last five presidential elections, Democrats have taken Wisconsin – the last two times by razor-thin margins. What does this mean for self-styled maverick John McCain in 2008? His campaign advisors think Wisconsin is promising … […]

  2. goofticket Says:


    Trying to reinforce the myths of McCain, with the spin terms of maverick, indie and th like are not going to sway any Wisconsin voter.
    This state leads the nation in Obama support with nearly 57% of the vote.
    This state does not, suddenly jump- willy nilly from one extreme to the other, in an election year.

    You forget we got burned, by the GOP this time. Massive national debt, careless-unchecked spending by Congress-resulting in less money to the states, and all the other issues. IRaq, Afghanistan, tainted China products, No Child’s Mindless Behind, and on an on. Not to mention the permanent scar the GOP left in the state.
    Joe McCarthy, and his tactics….we had two Supreme Court elections with old Joe’s style of politics.

    Wisconsin is not going red, anytime soon. We have moderate Dems, and the likes of Ryan and Senselessbrainer have angered state voters- with their lockstep to Bush.

    Wisconsin’s problems are from an obstinant and obstructive GOP Assembly playing games.
    Something the Wisconsin voters intend to fix this November.
    The GOP platform failed, and they get a pink slip and tine out to learn about the real world in 2009-10.
    It’s OK, we’ve done it before to the GOP.

  3. Chris Lato Says:


    goofticket - if I go along with your argument, does that mean the Democrats are culpable too, since they control Congress now?

    As for the Supreme Court stuff, meh. Everyone seems to forget WEAC dumping a ton of money into those races too.

    As for McCain, it’s true he has his work cut out for him, proving he won’t essentially offer a third term of Bush policies and decision-making. But he has also stepped away from the GOP on some key issues. This will be a tough race - it will not be a blowout in Wisconsin.

Leave a Reply

Avicom Political and Public Affairs